Not Just The Highest Prices Paid, The Most Honest


138 W. Main St. Somerville, NJ 88760

facebook logo-blue twitter logo-blue box

1570 Richmond Rd. Staten Island, NY 10304

home-support1-220-140 home-support2-220-140 home-support3-220-140 home-support4-220-140

We now have a second location in

Somerville, NJ in addition to our store in Staten Island, NY. Come visit us soon!

If you're buying or selling, Main Street Coin Shop is your number one destination. Our family owned and operated business has been giving the best prices and the best selection for over 30 years. For collectors and invenstors alike, we're your professional answer for all your collection needs.

If you wish to sell a coin collection or wish to turn your unwanted jewelry into cash, we purchase gold, silver (in all forms), and all US Mint  Coinage.  Once you do business with our family, you will tell yours about us.


Honesty and integrity is why we have been in business over 30 years.


We are not just dealers, we are collectors ourselves. We take pride in each & every coin we have in stock. From that last space in your Wheat Penny book, to that CC Morgan Dollar you need as your crown jewel, we are here as your source for only the best.

We have a vast selection of certified coins from NGC & PCGS as well.

Gold and Silver have been real money for 6000 years. Get the hedge you need with the lowest premiums around period.

Always free with no obligation at all. We are happy to take care of you in store, at your home or your bank.  Walk-ins are always welcome.

What we purchase

Coin collectors


Free appraisals

Great prices guaranteed Buy or sell your metals Invest with the best Let us help you choose